Learn the differences between Powder Bed Fusion and Ultrasonic Additive Manufacturing w/ Fabrisonic

Google+ Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr +


Often times when potential customers inquire about developing a new part, we get asked about the powders that we use in our 3D printing process. Powder Bed Fusion (PBF) is the ASTM standard name for 3D printing techniques based on a powder bed (DMLS, EBM, DLM, and SLM).

“Our 3D printing processes do not use powder”

Mark Norfolk, CEO at FABRISONIC

PBF is by far the most popular metal additive manufacturing process, due to its longevity in the industry and versatility.  However, there are commercially available 3D processes that do not use powders. One such process, Ultrasonic Additive Manufacturing (UAM), leverages commercially available metal foils. ASTM identifies this style of 3D printing as ‘sheet lamination’.  “As we will see below, there are fundamental differences between PBF and UAM that make each suited to different manufacturing needs.

How Powder Bed Fusion Works

PBF prints by selective melting of individual layers of metal powder.   First, a thin layer of powder is screened across a build plate. Next, a laser is selectively rastered to the areas where solid metal is required for a particular layer, thereby melting and re-solidifying these regions. The process is then repeated over and over, building up a solid 3D part. Once the build is complete, the loose unwelded powder is removed leaving the desired geometry.

While PBF works extremely well for complex organic structures that have intricate interwoven structure, there are aspects that should be evaluated when considering a 3D printing system:

-PBF works well with fusion weldable alloys. Since every layer is melted and resolidified, alloys that are known to be weldable are preferred. The melting inherent in the process makes it difficult to use alloys that are susceptible to solidification cracking. Precipitation hardened alloys in some cases can be printed, however, they must be heat treated after the build is complete to attain proper material properties. Typically, a single PBF system is restricted to one specific alloy as dissimilar metals create metallurgical problems and the systems are hard to ever truly get completely clean.

-PBF has been used with many common engineering metals. In order to print consistent PBF parts, it is essential for the feedstock powders to have a specific particle size, shape distribution, and metallurgical purity. A supply chain for these materials is developing, but the understanding of the complex interactions between all of the powder parameters will take years of research.

-PBF is perfectly suited for complex organic shapes where a rough surface finish is acceptable. As the part shape is governed by where the laser travels, each layer can be a mix of small islands, that when stacked, create hollow lattices and thin walls.   Due to the limitations on a laser’s scanning path and trouble maintaining sufficient inert shielding gas, PBF builds are typically restricted to about a cubic foot; constraining PBF to small components.  However, numerous parts can be nested in a single build to achieve higher throughput.

-Due to the fusion-based joining, PBF parts can have significant residual stresses. In fact, it is not uncommon for improperly supported builds to bow up above the build plane causing crashes with the powder recoating mechanism. This same residual stress when improperly dealt with can lead to parts failing prematurely in service.

How Ultrasonic Additive Manufacturing Works

How the UAM process compares to other metal AM printing process

UAM is ultrasonic welding on a semi-continuous basis where solid metal objects are built up to a net three-dimensional shape through a succession of welded metal tapes. Through periodic machining operations, detailed features are milled into the object until a final geometry is created by removing excess material.  Ultrasonic metal welding has been around since the 1950’s, with modern applications in everyday welding of battery tabs, thin foil packaging, and even electronic wires. An ultrasonic weld operation begins by pressing a thin metal foil onto another metal component. While under a constant force, ultrasonic vibrations are applied to cause scrubbing of the mating faces. This shearing motion cleans off surface oxides through friction, then allowing direct contact of pure metal on pure metal.

This process results in a  solid-state atomic bond with minimal heating. Ultrasonic welding can be accomplished at a very low temperature and without any special environments.  In aluminum for example, this peak temperature is always below 250 °F.

The solid-state nature is a key advantage of Ultrasonic Additive Manufacturing as it:

-Protects material properties of the incoming feedstock – Since the materials are only slightly heated, the materials do not experience changes in grain size, precipitation reactions, nor phase changes. The properties of the incoming feedstock are the same as the properties of the final part. Metal foils are widely available on the open market for prices approaching that of billet.

-Creates bonds between dissimilar metals without creating an undesirable brittle metallurgy – This capability differentiates UAM from fusion based processes and enables Fabrisonic to print engineered materials with custom material properties or properties to match an existing component. For instance, layers of Molybdenum and Invar can be printed into an aluminum heat exchanger to match the CTE of a mounted electronic circuit.

-Embed temperature sensitive components in solid metal parts – Many electronic components including microprocessors, sensors, and telemetry have been successfully embedded in solid metal part using UAM. The low-temperature bond allows delicate components to embed into solid metal without the damage incurred incomparable fusion based additive processes.

Find More Additive Manufacturing Industry News


additive manufacturing newsletter

Sources & More information

Related article categories:

Article and featured image:

Source: The article was gently conceded by Fabrisonic, and was re-edited by João Andrade on Dec2, 2018;